If you’ve recently completed “The Summer I Turned Pretty” (TSITP) and are now feeling a bit adrift without Belly, Conrad, Jeremiah, and the emotional whirlwind of Cousins Beach, you’re not alone. Many of us are replaying the soundtrack, scrolling through edits, and quietly pondering Team Conrad versus Team Jeremiah for the umpteenth time.
But fear not, the journey of swoony romance, messy love triangles, heartfelt family drama, and poignant coming-of-age moments doesn’t have to end here. There are numerous shows and movies that capture the same essence that captivated us in TSITP. Consider this a guide from one fan to another on what to watch next. Each recommendation offers a taste of TSITP, whether it’s the romance, the setting, or the emotional rollercoaster we secretly crave.
‘My Life with the Walter Boys’
Jackie Howard, after a tragic loss, relocates from New York City to rural Colorado to live with the Walters, a family with eleven kids, most of them boys. Initially overwhelming, Jackie’s adjustment soon turns into a whirlwind of sibling dynamics, first loves, and a love triangle between Alex, the reliable boy next door, and Cole, the charming heartbreaker. Fans of TSITP will appreciate the blend of heartwarming family moments and fluttering romance in this series. Much like Belly, Jackie finds herself torn between two divergent paths while navigating grief and self-discovery. It’s a compelling and addictive series where you’ll choose sides and defend them fervently in group discussions. If TSITP left you craving more drama infused with summer vibes, “Walter Boys” offers a similar mix with a mountain-town twist.
‘Outer Banks’
While TSITP revolves around sun-soaked coming-of-age romance, “Outer Banks” adds an exciting treasure-hunting element. Set on the North Carolina coast, the show follows John B and his crew of friends, the working-class Pogues, as they pursue hidden riches while clashing with the affluent Kooks. Romance blooms as John B falls for Sarah Cameron, a forbidden love across social divides. Viewers of TSITP will resonate with the themes of loyalty, love, and identity, as well as the vibrant beach-town ambiance that brings summer to life on screen. However, “Outer Banks” raises the stakes with thrilling chases, dark secrets, and life-or-death decisions. While it’s more intense and gritty than Jenny Han’s world, it satisfies the desire for heartfelt romance intertwined with complex choices. Picture TSITP with a treasure map and added danger, and you have the addictive chaos of “Outer Banks.”
‘XO, Kitty’
From Jenny Han herself comes “XO, Kitty,” a spinoff in her “To All the Boys” universe. Although not set on a beach, it exudes the same charm that made TSITP so enchanting: a teenage girl navigating first loves, cultural exploration, and self-discovery. Kitty Covey embarks on a journey to Korea to reunite with her long-distance boyfriend, only to find herself entangled in new crushes, unexpected friendships, and delightful chaos. Similar to Belly, Kitty is endearingly imperfect, figuring things out as she goes, which makes her highly relatable. The series, lighter and airier than TSITP, exudes a playful romantic comedy vibe while exploring themes of identity and belonging. Fans of Jenny Han’s skillful character development will find this spinoff irresistible. If TSITP was your summer retreat, “XO, Kitty” offers an international escapade that will warm your heart.
‘Dawson’s Creek’
Long before Belly had to choose between Conrad and Jeremiah, there was Joey Potter caught between Dawson Leery and Pacey Witter. “Dawson’s Creek” stands as one of the most iconic teen dramas, set in a tranquil coastal town where friendships evolve, heartaches sting, and growing up seems overwhelmingly complex. What makes it enduring—and a must-watch for TSITP enthusiasts—is its candid exploration of first love’s messiness. Joey’s relationships mirror Belly’s internal struggle between comfort and intensity, with dialogues that remain among the sharpest in teen television. Witnessing Joey row her boat to Dawson’s window evokes the same nostalgia as Belly’s moments at Cousins Beach. For viewers yearning for a classic, “Dawson’s Creek” offers a slow-burning emotional journey that set the stage for subsequent teen dramas. It’s heartfelt, anguished, and perfect for late-night marathons.
‘Never Have I Ever’
While Belly’s tale revolves around summer romance, Devi Vishwakumar’s journey delves into the tumultuous path of growing up, and it’s delightful chaos. Mindy Kaling’s teen dramedy strikes a balance between uproarious humor and poignant explorations of grief, identity, and the awkward rollerco